The most common question we get from homeowners early in the planning process is some version of: "Should I go with brick or stone?" It's a fair question. Both are excellent, long-lasting materials. But they behave differently, cost differently, and look different enough that the choice matters.
Here's an honest comparison based on what we actually see on projects in Abbotsford and the Fraser Valley.
Appearance and character
Brick has a regularity to it. The coursing is consistent, the dimensions are predictable, and the result is clean and formal. Traditional red brick reads as classic and residential. Charcoal or grey brick reads as modern. Brick suits houses where you want precision and uniformity — craftsman-style homes, colonial designs, modern farmhouse.
Stone has more variation. Even cultured stone, which is manufactured, has irregular shapes and colour variation that give it an organic, textural quality. Natural fieldstone or river rock takes that further — no two sections look exactly the same. Stone suits properties where you want a sense of weight, permanence, and connection to the landscape. It reads as more rustic or natural, which in the Pacific Northwest context often means it fits the environment better.
Neither is inherently "better looking." It depends on what your house already looks like and what character you're going for.
Durability in BC's climate
Both brick and stone hold up well in the Fraser Valley's climate when installed correctly. The key qualifier is "installed correctly" — which includes proper weather barriers, drainage, and flashing at any penetrations or ledges.
Brick is more susceptible to freeze-thaw damage if water gets into the brick itself, which is why the mortar type matters and why tuckpointing aging brick is important. Natural stone is generally denser and more freeze-thaw resistant, though porous stones like sandstone are less so.
Both materials will outlast every other exterior finish on a house when they're maintained properly. That's the primary reason to choose either one.
Cost
Brick is generally less expensive than natural stone for comparable coverage areas, because it's manufactured to a consistent size and installs more predictably. Cultured stone sits between the two — less expensive than natural stone, typically more expensive than brick.
Natural stone is the most expensive because of sourcing and installation time. Stone takes longer to lay because each piece has to be fitted individually. On large projects, that labour difference adds up significantly.
That said, cost shouldn't be the deciding factor on a material that's going on your house permanently. The difference in total project cost between brick and natural stone is real, but spread over 50+ years of use, it's not the most important variable.
Maintenance
Both brick and stone need mortar maintenance over time. Mortar joints should be inspected every 5–10 years and tuckpointed when they start to show recession or cracking. This is true regardless of material and is the main ongoing maintenance task.
Applying a breathable masonry sealer every 5–7 years is recommended for both materials in BC's wet climate. It reduces water absorption without trapping moisture inside the wall.
Neither material needs painting, staining, or replacement under normal circumstances. That's the point of choosing masonry in the first place.
The short answer
If you want precision, uniformity, and a classic residential look — brick. If you want texture, variation, and a more organic character that fits the Pacific Northwest landscape — stone. If you're budget-constrained, brick is the more economical choice. If you want the longest-lasting and most visually distinctive result, natural stone.
When we visit your property, we can look at your home's existing architecture and give you a recommendation based on what we actually think will look best and last the longest. That's worth a conversation before you commit to either.
Have a masonry project in mind?
We serve Abbotsford and the Fraser Valley. Give us a call or fill in the form for a free site visit and quote.
Ready to Talk Masonry?
Call us or send a quote request. Free site visit, clear written quote.
Licensed & Insured · BC Certified Masonry · Abbotsford, British Columbia